Science Comment - Advance Science

Comment thread

Reply to comment

This is a comment on: David Phillips and Andrew Kent Deconstructing Access Points by David Phillips and Andrew Kent ISSN: 1874-947X The Open Information Science Journal 2009 page 1-5 volume 2

Deconstructing Access Points by David Phillips and Andrew Kent ISSN: 1874-947X Volume 2, 2009   published on Monday, 22-Jun-09 10:38:21 CEST by JohnFrusciante

This is one example of why the “pay to publish” model has to end. Even top journals like PlOS can justify their fee schedule all they want, but at the end, pay to publish journals simply shift the revenue stream from institutions and readers(libraries and organizations) to the actual researcher, creating an incredible conflict of interest that compromises quality. As Peter Suber reports (http://www.earlham.edu/~peters/fos/2009/06/hoax-exposes-incompetence-or-worse-at.html), Bentham’s behavior has been questioned in the past. See, for example, this thread from liblicense in April 2008. http://www.library.yale.edu/~llicense/ListArchives/0804/msg00027.html I think it is possible to set up safeguards to avoid this conflict of interest. Let’s not paint all OA publishers with the same brush. On a lighter note, $800 seems like a bargain compared to other journals’ author fees!

Page 1 of 1
< previous next >

Reply to comment

Science Comment - Add your comment

Latest News

  • Use the power of ScienceComment and add your comment now!
    (2012-04-09 19:31:36)
  • Search function now working. You can search for keywords, doi and articles now. Test it!
    (2012-04-09 19:30:51)
  • List of journals has 4617 entries.
  • Now 31 comments online.